Posted in

Teenager Told Eddie Van Halen “You’re Playing Eruption WRONG” — On Guitar Hero

by Bien Tap Vien•

Eddie Van Halen was in a GameStop in Burbank browsing games with his son Wolf Gang when he heard the unmistakable opening of Eruption coming from a demo station. A teenage employee was playing Guitar Hero, absolutely destroying the song with a perfect score. Eddie walked over to watch. When the song ended, Eddie asked if he could try.

"
"

The teenager handed him the plastic guitar controller and said, “Sure, but fair warning, this is the hardest song in the game. Even people who play real guitar usually fail it.” Eddie smiled and started playing. After missing several notes, the teenager shook his head and said, “Dude, you’re playing it wrong. You’re not hitting the taps fast enough.

Here, let me show you the right technique.” Eddie handed back the controller. Wolf Gang standing nearby with his phone out was trying not to laugh. What happened in the next 60 seconds became an instant classic video on YouTube. It was a Saturday afternoon in June 2008, and 14-year-old Wolf Gang Van Halen had convinced his dad to take him to GameStop to pick up a new game.

Eddie had agreed, mostly because it gave them time to hang out together. Eddie was always touring or in the studio, so these simple errands together mattered. They walked into the GameStop in Burbank and Wolf Gang immediately headed to the new releases section. Eddie wandered toward the used games just browsing, enjoying being a regular dad doing regular dad things.

He was wearing jeans, a t-shirt, and a baseball cap, completely incognito, which was exactly how he liked it. Then he heard it, the opening tapping section of Eruption blasting from speakers near the front of the store. It was coming from a Guitar Hero demo station, and someone was playing his song. Eddie couldn’t resist.

He walked over to watch. A teenage employee name tag said Brandon, probably 17 years old, was absolutely shredding on the plastic guitar controller. His fingers were flying over the colored buttons, hitting every note on the TV screen. The note highway was a blur of colors, and the score multiplier kept climbing.

Brandon’s face was locked in concentration, his tongue sticking slightly out of the corner of his mouth. Eddie watched, genuinely impressed. The kid was good. Really good. He was hitting notes that Eddie knew from experience were incredibly difficult to time correctly in the game. When the song ended, Brandon threw his arms up in victory.

100% perfect score, five stars, the highest possible rating. “Nice,” Eddie said. “That looked hard,” Brandon grinned, still riding the high of his perfect run. “That’s the hardest song in the entire game. Most people can’t even get through it without failing. I’ve been practicing for weeks. Can I try? Eddie asked.

[snorts] Brandon looked at the middle-aged guy in the baseball cap. Probably somebody’s dad maybe played a little guitar back in college. Wanted to relive his glory days. Sure, man. But fair warning. This is Eruption by Van Halen. Even people who play real guitar usually fail it. The timing is insane. Eddie tried very hard not to smile. I’ll risk it.

Brandon handed over the plastic guitar controller. Eddie positioned it like he would a real guitar, which immediately felt wrong because the controller was shaped differently, weighted differently, responded differently. The buttons were in a line on the neck instead of frets. The strum bar clicked instead of producing actual sound.

Wolf Gang had noticed what was happening and drifted over with his phone already recording. He stood off to the side where Brandon couldn’t see him, barely containing his laughter. The song started. Eddie watched the screen trying to follow the note highway. The colored bars streaming down that told you which buttons to press and when to strum.

The opening tapping section came up and Eddie hit the buttons, but his timing was off. In real life, when Eddie played Eruption, his fingers moved by muscle memory developed over 30 years. On the plastic controller, that same muscle memory was useless. He missed a note, then another. The crowd meter, the visual indicator of how well you were doing, started dropping.

Eddie’s brain was trying to process, see color on screen, press corresponding button, strum at the right time. But the slight delay between his action and the game’s response was throwing him off. The tapping section that he could play in his sleep on a real guitar became a fumbling mess on the controller. Red, yellow, blue, yellow, red.

except the buttons didn’t feel right and his fingers kept hitting the wrong colors. The plastic strum bar clicked awkwardly under his thumb. This wasn’t music. This was a rapidfire pattern recognition test. The crowd meter dropped into yellow, then orange, then red. Eddie was failing at his own song. The screen flashed, failing in angry red letters.

Brandon was watching with a mixture of sympathy and barely contained amusement. See? Told you it’s hard. You’re playing it wrong, dude. Eddie looked at the teenager, genuinely curious. I’m playing it wrong? Yeah, you’re not hitting the taps fast enough, and your timing is off on the hammer ons.

You’re treating it like a real guitar. But Guitar Hero has its own technique. The game doesn’t care about music. It cares about button inputs. Here, let me show you. Brandon took back the controller and restarted the song. Okay, watch my fingers carefully. See how I’m doing the tapping section? You have to anticipate the notes slightly.

The game has a tiny delay between when you press the button and when it registers. So, if you play it exactly on time, like you would on a real guitar, the game thinks you’re late. You have to be like a split second early. Feel the rhythm of the game, not the rhythm of the music. Brandon’s fingers moved in precise mechanical motions.

Green, red, yellow, blue, yellow, red. not musical at all, but perfectly synchronized with the game’s demands. His eyes were locked on the screen, watching the notes approach, his fingers responding with computer-like precision. See, it’s all about learning the game mechanics. The actual guitar part doesn’t matter. What matters is understanding how the game reads your inputs.

It’s like, okay, you know how in a real guitar you can bend strings for expression? In this game, that doesn’t exist. There’s no expression, no feeling, no tone. Just did you press the right button at the exact millisecond the game wanted you to. That’s it. Eddie nodded slowly, fascinated by how Brandon had completely dissected the mechanics.

So, playing real guitar doesn’t actually help. Not really, Brandon said confidently. In fact, it usually makes it harder because you have muscle memory for the wrong thing. You’re thinking about music, melody, rhythm, expression. But Guitar Hero isn’t music. It’s a rhythm game. The best Guitar Hero players are people who learn the game first, not the instrument.

Read More