Posted in

She Said, “I’m Fine Alone”—But He Saw What Fine Was Hiding.

Could take a look at it if you’re needing. “No, thank you.” she said. “Yes, sir.” He touched his hat and rode on. The fifth morning he passed without stopping. “Morning.” called toward the fence line, not the house. She was at the window. She didn’t call back. Sixth morning the same. Seventh the same.

"
"

He didn’t stop again. Didn’t slow as he passed. Didn’t look toward the house with any expectation. He came each morning, tipped his hat toward the fence line, and went as regular as the mail. As indifferent to acknowledgement as the cold itself. After the second week, she stopped pretending not to listen for the sound of hooves on the frozen road.

On the eighth morning, there was a jar on her gate post. She saw it when she went out before full light to break the ice on the water trough. A glass jar, lid screwed tight, set square on the top of the gate post where she couldn’t miss it. He was already gone. She picked it up. Fence staples.

Not the heavy gauge the Whitmore spread used on their newer posts. The lighter gauge right for older wood. Right for her north fence line. The exact size she’d been meaning to pick up from the mercantile since October. He’d looked at her fence closely enough to know that. She stood in the cold with the jar in both hands. The sky not yet fully light.

The road empty in both directions. Something about the gauge. Something about the fact that he’d looked that carefully and said nothing about it to anyone. Including her. She brought the jar inside and put it on the shelf in the shed. Out of the cold. She didn’t know exactly why she didn’t leave it on the gate post to be returned. She just didn’t.

Same time. Two weeks of mornings. That was what it took for Iris to stop pretending the jar was an inconvenience waiting to be dealt with. She passed it twice in the shed once looking for the rawhide ties. Once for nothing in particular and left it where it was both times, on the shelf, out of the cold.

He came at the same time every day. She’d lived enough Wyoming winters to know that consistency meant something. Animals were consistent. A reliable well was consistent. It didn’t mean anything by itself, but it meant something was steady. And she’d learned to trust steady things more than clever ones. He didn’t stop again after that fourth morning.

He tipped his hat toward the fence line, whether she was at the window or at the gate or nowhere visible at all. The gesture had nothing to do with whether she was watching. On a Thursday in the last week of January, he slowed once. She was outside at the gate, she told herself, because the latch ice needed breaking. He pulled up, looked at the bowing fence section for a moment.

“That section’s going to drop in the next hard freeze,” he said. “Two weeks, maybe less.” “I know,” she said. He nodded, touched his hat brim, rode on. She stood at the gate after the hoofbeats had faded completely. The fence boards were right there, four of them. The lowest one bowed a full inch out of true. The post canting slightly north where the frost heave had started underneath.

She knew how to fix it, had fixed worse sections on her own, had the boards in the barn since October. She’d been meaning to get to it. Somehow it kept not getting gotten to. The cold worked through her gloves. She went back inside. That Sunday she went to church as usual. The homestead stood behind her, quiet and empty.

The north fence leaning a little more in the wind. Did you notice that? She knew how to fix that fence. Of course she did. She’d fixed every other thing on this homestead for 3 years running. But she hadn’t fixed it. And I’ve been thinking about that. What would make a capable woman leave the one thing undone? What do you think? I honestly don’t know what to make of it.

He fixed it. Anyway, she came home from church to find the fence repaired. New boards set clean and level. The leaning post straightened and packed solid in the frozen ground. The old bowed lumber stacked neatly to the side where she could burn it. The work was careful, the kind of man does when he’s not hurrying, when he’s thinking about what he’s doing rather than how fast he can finish.

An hour, maybe. Done in the cold on a Sunday morning without asking. Iris stood at the gate for a long moment. Then she saddled up and rode north to the Whitmore property. She found him mending wire at the far end of the east pasture. He looked up when she rode in, but didn’t stop working. “I didn’t ask for that.” She said.

“No, ma’am.” “I had the boards. I had the staples you left. I was going to fix it myself.” “Yes, ma’am.” “I expect you were.” “Then why?” She said. He looked at her then unhurried with the same steadiness he brought to everything else. “Because it needed doing.” She opened her mouth. Nothing came.

He touched his hat brim and turned back to his wire. She sat her horse for a moment longer, the wind off the mountains cutting straight through her coat. And then she turned and rode back without another word. That evening she sat at the table and tried to sort out what she was feeling. It wasn’t gratitude, exactly. It wasn’t offense, though she’d ridden over there with something like offense.

It was more like the feeling you get when someone reads something in your face you’d believed was hidden, a brief involuntary exposure followed by the impulse to look away. The fence had been wrong. She knew it was wrong. She’d been leaving it wrong. She turned that over for a long time. Her coffee went cold.

Outside, the repaired fence stood solid in the dark, the new boards pale against the weathered posts, straight and still, catching the last of the moon. She got up to put her cup in the basin, stopped. “Coffee’s on.” She said to the empty kitchen. Quietly, as though testing the sound of it, she poured a second cup, set it on the near end of the table where there was room for someone else to sit.

The next morning when he passed, she was at the gate. “Coffee’s on.” She said, “If you’ve got a few minutes.” He looked at her. “Much obliged, ma’am.” He tied his horse and followed her inside. “What you had to ride away from?” They sat at the near end of the table, not at Daniel’s end. Jesse had taken the chair that faced the window, the one closer to the stove, without being directed and without choosing it conspicuously.

He simply sat where there was room. She set the cups down and they were quiet for a moment. The fire doing the only talking. She noticed early on that he held his cup with both hands, the habit of a man who had spent years watching weather, watching the horizon to know whether the cold was coming fast or slow, whether the herd needed moving before nightfall.

She said nothing about it, but when his cup was half gone, she refilled it before he asked. And he looked at the cup for a moment, then at her, and said nothing either. “Where were you before Wyoming?” she asked. The question surprised her. She hadn’t planned it. He looked at his coffee. “Kansas. Had a place up near Dodge, ran cattle on about 300 acres.

Read More