Posted in

John Wayne walked into a shoe store in Arizona in 1961: what he saw on that shelf left him speechless.

>>  >> He had been coming to Tucson from California for 3 days, taking the kind of route that only makes sense to a man who drives long distances often enough to know that the most direct way between two points is  sometimes the least useful one. He wasn’t in a hurry. The picture was done. The Comancheros, 6 weeks in the Arizona heat, and he was heading back to California in the way of a man who had earned the right to take 3 days about it.

"
"

The address was written on a piece of paper he’d kept in the same wallet for 4 years. John Ford had given it to him on a Tuesday afternoon in 1957 between setups on a location shoot outside Flagstaff. Ford handed it over the way he handed over everything important, without ceremony, with the implication that a man who couldn’t understand why it mattered probably wasn’t worth explaining it to.

Ed Estess’s boy, shops on Mesquite Street behind the hardware. Last man in Arizona making real boots. He’d said it once. He didn’t repeat it. Look, before this story goes further, you have to understand what John Ford meant by the word real, because it’s the same word that had been sitting in Wayne’s chest like a splinter for 6 weeks by the time he turned onto Mesquite Street.

The picture had wrapped well overall, but the prop department’s boots had been  off. Not wrong enough for anyone in the audience to identify, not right enough for the man wearing them to forget. Lightweight, preformed, the kind of thing a studio accountant loved because it could be ordered in quantity at a discount and would photograph adequately under lighting.

Wayne had put them on every morning for 6 weeks and felt the difference with every step on every surface. He hadn’t made a production of it. He just felt it quietly the way you feel anything that isn’t what it should be. He’d driven past the hardware store twice before he found the alley. The sign above the narrow door was painted wood.

The letters done by hand in black, Estes Boots,  S S’t 1921. Below it, a smaller line that looked like it had been added later in a slightly different hand, handmade to order. The sign looked exactly like what it was, something  built to last and not concerned with looking like anything else.

He pulled the truck to the end of the alley and got out. Roy Estes was 67 years old, which Wayne didn’t know yet but would have placed within two or three years from the way the man moved. Not broken down, not slow, but carrying a weight that had nothing to do with his joints. He had the hands of a man who had worked leather every day for 50 years, darkened at the creases, precise at the fingertips, still strong in a way that had become automatic and therefore invisible to their owner.

He was turning a key in the door lock when he heard the truck. He turned around. Standing in the alley behind him was a very large tan man in a faded work shirt and canvas trousers and a battered Stetson holding a piece of paper and looking at the sign. “You Roy Estes?” the man said. “That’s right. John Ford sent me.

” Roy looked at him without recognition. “John Ford, film director. We worked together. I know who John Ford is.” Roy considered the the being held out to him. He didn’t take it. “He sent you 4 years ago, looks like.” He nodded at the date on the corner. The large man glanced at the paper.

“Took me a while to get to Tucson.” Roy unlocked the door. He didn’t invite the man in yet, but he didn’t tell him to leave either, which in Roy’s economy of gesture was the same as a welcome. “Come in then,” he said, “though I’ll tell you now, I was about to close.” He wasn’t. He was about to close permanently.

But he said it the way he’d said everything in the past 3 weeks, carefully, keeping the larger fact inside it, not letting it out where it could do anything. Notice what happens in the next 10 minutes. This is where the story could have turned into something ordinary, a man looking at boots, a craftsman showing his work, a transaction. It didn’t.

It became something else entirely, and the reason is a pair of boots that Roy Estes had made 9 years earlier and never sold. The shop was small and smelled of leather and beeswax and the particular dry warmth of an Arizona afternoon. Boots lined three walls, finished pairs on wooden stands, works in progress on the bench, hides rolled and stacked in the corner.

Wayne stopped in the doorway and looked at it the way a man looks at a room when he’s trying to take in its full dimension before he commits to entering.  He stepped inside. He went to the nearest finished pair, dark brown, round toe, a simple stitch pattern on the shaft, and picked it up. He ran his thumb along the welt, pressed the sole, checked the stitching at the heel.

“How long on a pair like this?” he said. “Three weeks, four if the hide needs work.” “What’s the hide?” “Cow hide, vegetable tanned. I don’t use chrome tanning, it weakens the grain over time.” Roy said it without special emphasis, the way a man states facts about his own work when someone asks the right question. Wayne set the boot down and picked up another, a different style, narrower toe, a more elaborate stitch.

He turned it over. “What do you get for them?” “95 for the plain ones, 120 for the worked ones. Wayne nodded slowly. He already knew what was coming before he asked it. And the factory boot? Roy’s jaw moved once, barely. $18 at the hardware store, three doors up. He paused. They sell quite a few. Before we go any further, hold this image.

A man who has spent 50 years learning to do one thing exactly right, watching the world pay $18 for a version of that thing that will last three years, and still here, still making them, still doing it the only way he knows how to do it, which is the right way, because the other way is not something he can bring himself to practice, even now.

Wayne set the boot down. He was about to say something when he saw the pair on the shelf in the back corner. They were different from everything else in the shop. Not in style, the same round toe, the same careful stitching, different in something harder to name. They sat in a box, tissue paper folded back, unwrapped.  They had never been worn.

You could see it in the leather, that particular unbroken quality of something made with great care and then kept, rather than used. He crossed to the back of the shop. Roy watched him go. “Those aren’t for sale.” Roy said. Flat, immediate, no explanation. Stop for a second and feel the weight of that sentence.

A man who is about to lose his  shop, who has been told by the bank that this week is the end, and he has one pair of boots on his shelf that he will not sell. The reason for that is the whole center of this story, and Roy Estes was not going to tell  it to a stranger who had walked in off the alley with a piece of paper from four years ago. “Fair enough.” Wayne said.

He didn’t push. He moved back to the front of the shop and picked up another pair. It was that, the two words,  and the stepping back, that changed something in Roy’s posture. A man who has been on guard for a long time, waiting for the push that doesn’t come, has to reconfigure himself when it doesn’t.

Read More