Posted in

That’s Not My Baby,” She Cried — The Cowboy Looked Closer… And Froze in Terror

Eddie set the bundle on the table gently, though he didn’t know why, and poured the woman water from the pitcher. She drank it in three long gulps, gasping between each one. When she was done, she sat very still, staring at the thing on the table. “What’s your name?” Caleb asked. “Nora! Nora Callaway?” “I’m Caleb Thornton.” “This is my land.

"
"

” “You’re safe here?” she laughed sharp and bitter. “Safe?” Caleb didn’t know what to say to them, so he said nothing. He sat across from her and together they stared at the bundle on the table. The blanket had fallen open slightly and he could see one small hand fingers curled, nails perfectly formed. It looked so much like a baby, but it wasn’t. He knew that now.

The way you know a storm’s coming before you see the cloud. Something in his gut older than thought, screaming at him to get it out of his house. What do we do with it? Norah whispered. Caleb didn’t have an answer. They buried it at first. Not in the cemetery. Caleb wouldn’t do that.

Wouldn’t let that thing lie near Martha’s grave, but out past the chicken coupe, where the ground was soft and the mosquite grew thick. Norah didn’t want to touch it, so Caleb wrapped it tighter in the blanket and carried it himself. It weighed almost nothing, like kindling. He dug the hole 3 ft deep, working in silence, while Norah stood a few paces back, arms wrapped around herself.

When he was done, he lowered the bundle into the earth and paused. “Should I say something?” he asked. Norah shook her head. “It’s not a baby. Still feels wrong not to.” “Then say what you want, but don’t ask God to take it. Don’t give it a name.” Caleb didn’t argue. He just filled in the hole, tamped down the dirt, and marked the spot with a flat stone.

When he turned around, Norah was crying again, silent tears streaming down her face. “I’m sorry,” she said. “I know you think I’m a coward. I don’t. I should have stayed. I should have looked for them, but I ran. I just I ran. Caleb wiped the dirt from his hands. You did what you had to. Now, we’re going to that camp and we’re going to find out what happened.

She looked at him startled. You can’t. You don’t know what’s out there. Neither do you. I know enough to be afraid. Then stay here. I’ll go alone. No. She said it fast, like the word had been yanked out of her. No, I’ll come. I have to know. They rode out an hour later, Caleb on his own gilding and Norah on Martha’s old mare.

The morning was cold and bright, the sky scrubbed clean by the wind. Caleb kept his rifle across his lap, eyes scanning the scrub for movement. Nora rode behind him, silent except for the creek of leather and the soft jingle of the bright river was exactly where she said it would be. A muddy ribbon cutting through the cottonwoods, and there on the near bank with the wagons, four of them, all empty.

Caleb dismounted slowly, every sense screaming at him to turn around. The wagons were intact, canvas still tied down, wheels unbroken, but there were no horses, no mules, no people, no sound at all. Norah slid from her horse and walked toward the nearest wagon, moving like she was underwater. Caleb followed rifle up. The first wagon belonged to a family.

He could tell by the clutter, pots and pans hanging from hooks, a child’s doll wedged between two crates. The bedding was rumpled like someone had gotten up in a hurry, but there was no blood. No sign of struggle. Nora, she turned. Caleb pointed to the ground. Tracks. Dozens of them. Small barefoot prints leading away from the camp heading north into the scrub.

They were shallow, barely impressions, but they were there. Children, Norah whispered. Or something that wanted us to think. She looked at him and he saw the fear crystallize in her eyes. They searched the other three wagons. Same story. belongings left behind, bedding disturbed, no people. In the last wagon, Caleb found a cradle.

It was handcarved, beautiful work, lined with soft cloth. Inside was a blanket neatly folded. And on the blanket, something small and dark. Caleb reached for it, a lock of hair, tied with a red thread. He showed it to Nora, and she made a sound like she’d been hit. “That’s mine,” she said. “That’s from my baby.

I cut it the day he was born. Where’s the rest of him?” she didn’t answer. just sank to her knees and pressed her hands over her mouth rocking. Caleb stared at the lock of hair and a cold sick certainty settled over him. Whatever had taken the baby, her real baby had left something else in its place. “We need to go,” he said quietly.

“Now!” Norah nodded, but she didn’t move. “Nora! Now,” she stood shaking and let him pull her back to the horses. They mounted and turned north, following the tracks. The prince led them two miles into the scrub winding through mosquite and cactus. Then stopped abruptly at the base of a low ridge. There was nothing there, no bodies, no camp, no sign of where 15 people had gone. Just silence.

And then from somewhere behind them a sound, a baby crying. Norah whipped around, eyes wide. Do you hear that? Caleb heard it high and thin, barely louder than the wind. Stay close, he said. They followed the sound back toward the river, and the crying grew louder, more insistent. It was coming from the wagons, the same wagons they’ just searched.

Caleb’s blood turned to ice. When they reached the camp, the crying stopped, and sitting in the dirt, right where they’ buried it that morning was the bundle, unwrapped, unburied. The thing inside staring up at them with open eyes. Caleb didn’t remember raising the didn’t remember pulling the hammer back, but suddenly it was aimed.

Barl, trembling, pointed at the thing sitting in the dirt. Don’t, Norah whispered. Her voice was hollow. Don’t shoot it. Why the hell not? Because I don’t think it’ll The thing, he couldn’t call it a baby anymore. Couldn’t even think of it that way. Tilted its head. Slow, deliberate, like it was studying them.

The eyes were open now, pale gray, and unblinking. The mouth hung slightly, a jar showing pink gums. note. But the lips were moving just barely, forming shapes that might have been words if anything living had spoken them. Caleb’s finger tightened on the trigger. Then the crying started again, but not from the thing in the dirt from behind them.

Norah spun, and Caleb heard her breath catch. He didn’t turn. Oh, couldn’t. His eyes were locked on the thing, watching it watch him. But he heard it, the crying. Multiple voices now overlapping coming from the wagons. Caleb. Norah’s voice cracked. Caleb, look. He risked a glance and his stomach dropped.

There were more of them sitting in the wagons, propped against the wheels, lying in the dirt. Six, seven, too many, all the same size, same pale skin, same wrong proportions, and all of them crying in unison. A sound that drilled into his skull like a nail. Jesus Christ, he breathed. They’re the children, Norah said. The ones from the camp.

Read More