Posted in

Wealthy Women Was Pitied for Being Barren — Father Said, “I Already Have Children. I Just Need Her.”

“It’s okay. It was 2 years ago. I still miss her, but papa says missing someone means you love them, and that’s never a bad thing.” Behind them Rosie heard footsteps approaching. She looked over her shoulder to see papa walking toward them, his hat in his hands, his face a mixture of embarrassment and something else.

"
"

Something she couldn’t quite read. “I’m sorry, ma’am.” Papa’s voice was careful, the way it always was around strangers. “My daughter sometimes acts before she thinks.” “Papa, this is” Rosie looked at the lady. “What’s your name?” The lady rose to her feet, brushing dirt from her dress, though she didn’t seem to care about the stains.

Her eyes met Papa’s and Rosie watched something pass between them. A spark maybe, or a question. “Eleanor.” The lady said. “Eleanor Ashford.” Rosie heard a sharp intake of breath from somewhere behind her. Turned to see Mrs. Pruitt watching from near the church steps. Her circle of four women all staring in their direction.

Mrs. Pruitt’s mouth was pressed into a thin line. “Look at her.” Mrs. Pruitt said, loud enough to carry. “Buying his attention with that fancy dress. As if a man like Thomas Wheeler would look twice without the money behind it.” >> The words didn’t make sense to Rosie. Buying attention? What did that mean? But she saw the way Miss Ellie’s face changed.

The way her shoulders pulled in, just slightly. The way her hand moved unconsciously to her stomach, touching it. Then dropping away as if she’d caught herself doing something forbidden. >> Papa didn’t respond to Mrs. Pruitt. He just tipped his hat to Miss Ellie. “Thomas Wheeler, ma’am. This is Rosie, and my other two are He gestured toward the oak tree, where Samuel’s now poking something with a stick, and Martha was sitting in the dirt eating grass.

Over there, being themselves. Miss Ellie’s lips curved. Not quite a smile, but almost. They seem like good children. They are. They’re also loud, messy, and prone to mischief. But they’re mine. Papa reached for Rosie’s hand. Come on, Rosebud. Let the lady enjoy her morning. >> Rosie let him take her hand. But she looked back at Miss Ellie as they walked away.

And she saw something that stayed with her for days afterward. Miss Ellie was still standing by the cemetery fence alone watching them go. And her hand was on her stomach again. Touching the empty space there, and her eyes were the saddest eyes Rosie had ever seen. >> The Wheeler cabin had three rooms and a leaky roof.

Rosie had lived there her whole life, but she saw it differently now through the filter of Miss Ellie’s fancy dress and fine gloves. The cabin was small, 600 square feet, Papa said once. But Rosie didn’t know what that meant exactly. It meant she shared a bed with Samuel and Martha in one room while Papa slept in another.

And the third room was for cooking and eating and everything else. The roof leaked in two spots, which Papa kept patching with tar paper and prayers. The walls were log and chinked with mud, and the windows had real glass, which Papa said was a luxury. It didn’t feel like a luxury to Rosie. It just felt like home. The evening after church, Papa sat at the rough-hewn table while Rosie helped Martha eat her porridge.

Samuel was outside doing his chores, which meant he was probably talking to the chickens instead of feeding them. The lady at church, Papa said, his voice too casual. Miss Ashford, you knew her name? Rosie looked up. She told me. After I hugged her. You just walked up and hugged her? She looked sad, Papa. Nobody was talking to her.

She was standing all by herself, and everyone was walking past her like she wasn’t there. Rosie spooned more porridge into Martha’s mouth. Why does everyone do that? Why don’t they talk to her? Papa was quiet for a long time. Long enough that Rosie counted. She’d learn to count silences after Mama died. Because silences meant Papa was thinking about hard things.

6 minutes. Sometimes, he said finally, people talk about things they don’t understand. And sometimes they’re cruel because they don’t know how else to be. But why don’t they understand? What’s wrong with Miss Ellie? Papa’s hand tightened on his coffee cup. Nothing’s wrong with her, Rosie. Nothing at all. The next evening, Mrs. Harmon came by.

Mrs. Clara Harmon was 68 years old, which seemed impossibly ancient to Rosie. She had been a school teacher before the school burned down in the dry summer 3 years ago. And now she taught Sunday school and did mending for families who couldn’t afford the tailor in town. She came to the Wheeler cabin every Tuesday with a basket of mended clothes and kind word for anyone who needed one.

Rosie liked her because she never talked to children like they were stupid. Thomas, Mrs. Harmon settled into the only good chair, the one Papa always offered her. I saw your daughter make quite an impression on Sunday. Papa was at the stove stirring something that smelled like beans and not much else. Yes, ma’am.

I’m sorry if Don’t apologize. It was the most human thing I’ve seen in that churchyard in months. Mrs. Harmon accepted the cup of coffee Papa handed her. That poor girl’s been standing alone at every gathering since her husband died. 18 months now. No one talks to her. No one visits. They just whisper. Rosie was supposed to be doing her letters at the table, but she was listening.

She’d learned a lot by listening. “Why?” Papa asked. His back was to Mrs. Harmon, but Rosie could hear something in his voice. Interest, maybe more than interest. Mrs. Harmon was quiet for a moment. Then she said, “You know what barren means, Thomas?” “Yes, ma’am.” Her husband made sure everyone knew. Used to say it at parties, at church gatherings, wherever he could get an audience.

“My wife, the barren one.” Like she was a field that wouldn’t grow crops. Like she was defective. Mrs. Harmon’s voice went hard, and Rosie stopped pretending to write. He married her for her father’s money, then spent 10 years reminding her she couldn’t give him an heir. When he died, fell from his horse, drunk. Couldn’t happen to a nicer man.

He left her the fortune and the reputation. Everyone knows. Everyone remembers. “That’s not her fault,” Papa said. “No, it’s not. But people don’t care about fault. They care about having someone to pity, someone to look down on. Makes them feel better about their own miseries.” Rosie watched Papa turn from the stove.

His face had that look again, the one she couldn’t quite read. “She seems kind.” “She is kind, kinder than this town deserves.” Mrs. Harmon studied him for a long moment. Her eyes sharp despite her age. “Why are you asking, Thomas?” Papa didn’t answer right away. When he did, his voice was careful. Just curious. Rosie seemed to like her.

Mrs. Harmon smiled, a knowing sort of smile that made Rosie suspect she wasn’t fooled at all. Let me tell you something, Thomas Wheeler. Something I’ve learned in 68 years on this earth. She set down her coffee cup. The best marriages I ever saw weren’t built on what people brought. They were built on what people became together.

Read More