Posted in

Cast Out at 19, She Bought an Abandoned Homestead for $3—What She Found Shocked the Valley

She was 19 and homeless. No family left who would claim her. No money beyond what she could carry in a coffee tin. Just a wool blanket that had belonged to her grandmother and three copper coins that together amounted to exactly $3. And with that $3 she bought an abandoned homestead at the far end of the Corbin Valley.

"
"

A place so forgotten that even the county assessor had crossed it off his ledger with a single line of ink. But what nobody knew, not the clerk who sold it, not the ranchers who rode past it without looking, not even the woman who would pry up the rotted planks with her own hands, was that beneath those floorboards lay something that would change her life and the life of every person in that Valley forever.

If you have not yet subscribed to this channel, take a moment now because this story is one you will want to hear from beginning to end. Her name was Alara Cain and she was born on the 7th of March in a narrow clapboard house on the outskirts of Harlan. A mill town pressed into the crease between two ridges where the Elk River ran shallow over limestone.

Her father was Thomas Cain, a timber cruiser who walked the high forests marking trees for the Harlan Lumber Company. And her mother was Josephine Cain, née Pruitt, who had come to Harlan at 17 to work in the company store and who married Thomas six months later in a ceremony attended by 11 people and a dog that belonged to no one in particular.

Alara was their second child. Her brother David was 4 years older and quiet in the way that oldest children in poor families often are, carrying responsibilities he never asked for with a patience that looked, from the outside, like indifference. The family was not destitute, but they were close enough to it that the difference was academic.

Thomas earned 40 cents a day plus board when he was in the field, and Josephine took in mending and kept a kitchen garden that fed them through the summers, and when the canning went well, into the early months of winter. They owned the house, but not the land beneath it, which was leased from the lumber company at a rate that rose a little every year, the way water rises in a cellar, slowly enough that you do not notice until your boots are wet.

Elara’s childhood was shaped by two things, work and her grandmother, Bett Pruitt, who lived alone in a cabin 4 miles up the ridge road, and who was, by any honest accounting, the most capable person Elara ever knew. Bett had been widowed at 31 when her husband, a man named Oren Pruitt, was killed by a falling spruce during a windstorm in the winter of 1847.

She had raised Josephine and Josephine’s two brothers alone on that ridge, growing potatoes and turnips in soil so rocky. She once told Elara that she could have planted a stone and harvested a boulder. Bett was small and lean, and her hands were the hands of someone who had never stopped working. The knuckles swollen, the fingers curved slightly inward even at rest.

The skin across her palms as thick and smooth as saddle leather. She wore her white hair in a single braid that hung to the middle of her back, and she had a way of looking at you when you spoke that made you feel that every word you said was being weighed and measured and stored somewhere permanent. It was Bett who taught Elara to use tools.

Not in the way that children are sometimes taught. Handed a hammer and told to tap gently at a nail already started. But properly. With seriousness and expectation. By the time Alara was 10, she could sharpen a drawknife on an oilstone, true the edge of a plane blade, and split a shingle from a cedar bolt with a froe and mallet.

By 12, she could hang a door so that it swung true and latched clean. And she could read the grain of a board well enough to know which face to put up and which to put down, and where the wood would want to cup if you let it dry unevenly. Bett taught her these things not with lectures, but with demonstration and correction.

Standing beside her at the workbench in the little shed behind the cabin, guiding Alara’s hands with her own when the angle was wrong, saying only, “Feel that? That is the wood telling you where it wants to go.” Bett believed that every material had a nature, and that the job of the person working it was to understand that nature and cooperate with it rather than fight it.

And she extended this philosophy to people as well. Though she was less patient with people than she was with wood. When Alara was 14, her father was injured in the forest. A dead limb, what the timbermen called a widowmaker, fell from a hemlock and struck him across the shoulders. And though it did not kill him, it broke something in his back that never healed correctly.

He came home on a stretcher made from two poles and a canvas sheet, and he never walked into the forest again. The lumber company gave him nothing. No payment, no pension, no acknowledgement beyond a notation in the foreman’s ledger that read, “T. Cain, retired from service.” Thomas spent the next 2 years in a chair by the window, growing thinner and quieter.

And Josephine worked longer hours at the mending and took on laundry as well. And David, who was 18 by then, went to work at the mill itself, feeding logs into the saw carriage for 35 cents a day. Elara divided her time between the house where she cooked and cleaned and tended her father and Bett’s cabin, where she continued to learn.

It was during this period that Bett gave her the object she would carry for the rest of her life. A small folding knife with a bone handle and a blade that had been reground so many times it was narrow as a willow leaf. It had belonged to Orin Pruitt. Bett placed it in Elara’s palm one afternoon without ceremony and said, “He would have liked you.

You pay attention the way he did.” Elara closed her fingers around it and felt the warmth of the bone and the weight of the brass bolsters, and she understood that she was being given something that could not be replaced. Thomas Cain died in the autumn of that year, on a Tuesday, with the windows open and the smell of wood smoke coming in from somewhere down the road.

He was 43 years old. Josephine sold the house, or rather surrendered it back to the lumber company in exchange for the cancellation of 2 years of back rent, and moved with David into a boarding house in town. Elara went to live with Bett for 2 years, from the time she was 15 until she was 17. Elara lived in the ridge cabin, and those were, she would later say, the best years of her life.

She and Bett worked side by my every day, mending the cabin, tending the garden, cutting firewood, putting up food for winter. Bet taught her to lay a stone foundation, to mix lime mortar, to read weather in the movement of birds and the color of the sky at evening. They did not talk a great deal, but the silence between them was the silence of two people who understood each other completely.

Read More