Posted in

The Law Said This Girl Had To Go Home — Her Door In The Cliff Proved Otherwise

The sheriff saw the door before he saw the girl. That was the part he would remember. Not the smoke, not the creak, not even the pistol on his own hip, which suddenly felt like the least useful object a man had ever carried into the mountains. The door was hanging beneath a limestone shelf where no house had any right to be.

"
"

Four pine planks, one crossbrace, a leather hinge, a wooden latch polished by use. Behind it, warm smoke breathed out of a stone chimney built into the cliff. In front of it, a late bean patch climbed a lattice of split cane. A brown hen scratched near a water bucket. Strips of cured rabbit hung above a clean hearth. But on a flat rock beside the doorway, sat a girl of 17 mending a basket with an awl in her hand.

She had seen Sheriff Amos Rusk before he left the creek bed. She had watched him climb through the laurel. She had watched his deputy come after him, stepping too loud, one hand on a rifle, thinking the woods were empty because no one had answered him. The girl did not stand. She did not run. She pulled the white oak strip through the basket wall, tightened it with her thumb, and looked at the sheriff as if he were the one who had wandered somewhere he did not belong.

Amos Rusk had been sheriff of Letcher County for 12 years. He had seven illegal stills, two stolen horses, one dead gambler in a chestnut hollow, and more family trouble than any lawman could carry without it changing the way he slept. When a farmer from Little Stone Gap reported a line of smoke above Bear Wallow Creek in October of 1887, Amos thought he knew what he was riding toward.

A still, a copper worm, two men lying badly, maybe one man running. Instead, he found a door in the mountain, a winter’s worth of food, and a girl who had built a life out of the very country everyone else had told her would kill her. The law gave him a simple duty. Her father was alive, she was underage, her belonged in her father’s custody.

And in the 10 minutes after Amos Rusk saw that door, he decided he was not going to obey the law in the simple way the law expected to be obeyed. But that is where this story nearly ends. Where it begins is 11 months earlier, on a Sunday morning, when 16-year-old Myra N. Treadway walked away from a cabin that had never once been locked because no one inside it believed she was capable of leaving.

Sunday was the safest day to disappear. Not because the road was empty, because it was full. The church bell at Dry Fork pulled people from every hollow within 6 miles. Men walked in coats brushed clean with corn husks. Women carried babies on one hip and hymnals in the other hand. Children were washed hard enough to shine.

A person could move with that river and not be seen as a person at all. Just motion. Just another dark dress. Just another bowed head under a bonnet. Myra N. waited until her father and brother had gone ahead toward the church road, both of them late, both of them angry about being late. Neither of them noticing that she had not followed.

Then she took the feed sack from beneath the bedboards. Inside it were seven things. A coil of rabbit wire, a striker and flint, a tin cup, a blanket that had belonged to her mother, a packet of dried beans wrapped in paper, an iron awl with a walnut handle, and the knife from the smokehouse beam. Not her brother’s knife, not her father’s knife, the old knife her mother had used for cutting cane, cleaning fish, and trimming basket splits so fine they curled like hair.

Maren took no shoes. Her only pair had cracked across both soles the winter before, and her brother Bram had laughed when she stuffed them with rag to make them last. For 4 months she had been walking barefoot whenever she could, to the spring, to the corn patch, along the branch where the stones were sharp enough to teach a lesson.

At first her feet bled, then they hardened. By November, the ground that would have punished her in May had become simply ground. This was how Maren prepared. Not with speeches, not with declarations, with small changes no one in the cabin thought important enough to notice. To understand why she left, you have to understand what the cabin had become after her mother died.

And to understand that, you have to understand what her mother had been. Elien Treadway had come into Kentucky from the Wise County side when she was 19, carrying a cedar chest, a packet of bean seed, and a knowledge of the mountains that never once announced itself as knowledge. She knew which bank held watercress before the frost lifted, cane without splitting it.

She knew that squirrels ran the same high limbs every morning until pressure changed in the air. She knew where the yellow root grew, where the pawpaws ripened, where the creek hid fish beneath the undercut clay. She knew how to make a basket tight enough to hold meal and loose enough to breathe. And she knew that a girl who could use her hands was never completely poor.

Maren learned without being told she was learning. Her mother did not give lectures. She gave work. “Watch this knot. Hold the split flat. Do not force the blade. If the cane fights you, turn it. Your hands will know before your head catches up.” That was the sentence Maren kept. “Your hands will know.” She was 9 years old the last time her mother said it.

They were sitting beside the branch in late August, soaking cane in a wash tub. Elion put the awl into Maren’s palm and curled the girl’s fingers around the walnut handle. “This is not for stabbing,” she said. “It is for opening a place where something can pass through.” Then she showed her how to pierce the basket wall without breaking it, how to make a gap, how to thread strength through it.

A month later, fever took Elion in three nights. By the fourth morning, the cabin still contained her apron on its peg, her cup on the shelf, her comb beside the wash basin, not contain the thing that had made the cabin a place instead of a structure. Silas Treadway, her husband, buried her under two chestnut trees above the spring.

He was a cooper then, a maker of barrels and churns, not a great craftsman, but a useful one. His hands knew how to make staves lean together until they held water. They knew the patience of hoops and heat and swelling grain. For 1 year after Elion died, his hands kept working. For the second year, they worked when they had to.

By the third, they mostly held a jug. The tools in the shed rusted in their rack. The shave horse split down the middle from weather. Barrel he made stood in the corner of the cabin, a tight white oak flour barrel with Elion’s initials burned under the rim. Bram used it as a seat when his boots were muddy. Maren saw it every day.

She saw the proof that her father had once known how to make something useful and watertight. That proof made his failure worse. A man who had never held anything together might have been easier to forgive. After Elion died, the house did not ask who was old enough to carry it. It only began falling. So Maren carried it.

Read More